Foundation first: who wants what
Before you read the four parts, remember what each person wants.
| Person | What he or she wants | How it shows |
|---|---|---|
| King Francis | an exciting show | "loved a royal sport" |
| The lady | glory and admiration | "great glory will be mine" |
| Count de Lorge | to show his courage, and keep his dignity | he leaps, then throws the glove back |
The story is a clash between the lady's wish for glory and the Count's sense of what is right. The King, who sees all of it, gives the verdict.
Part 1 (lines 1–6) — The royal spectacle
King Francis was a "hearty" (jovial, full-blooded) king who loved a "royal sport" — watching his lions fight. One day, as they fought, he sat watching with his court. The nobles filled the benches, with the ladies sitting proudly among them, and among them sat Count de Lorge with the lady he loved ("one for whom he sighed"). (2027 specimen Q6(i): King Francis, nobles and ladies seated together, watching the lions fight in the pit; Count de Lorge sighing for his beloved.)
It was truly a "gallant" (splendid, noble) sight — a "crowning show" of all that a court admired: "Valour and love, and a king above, and the royal beasts below." The line neatly arranges the scene from top to bottom: the King high on his seat, the knights' valour and the ladies' love around him, and the "royal beasts" (lions, kings of animals) in the pit below. (2027 specimen Q6 extract.)
Part 2 (lines 7–12) — The lion fight
The poet now plunges us into the fight with powerful sound and visual images:
- The lions "ramped and roared" (reared up and roared), with "horrid laughing jaws" — their open jaws look like a terrible grin.
- They bit, they glared, they struck "blows like beams" (heavy wooden beams); "a wind went with their paws" — their swipes were so powerful they stirred the air.
- With "wallowing might and stifled roar" they rolled on one another, till the whole pit was a "thunderous smother" of sand and mane — a choking cloud of dust and fur.
- "The bloody foam" from their mouths flew "above the bars", whisking through the air towards the spectators.
(2027 specimen Q6(ii): visual images — laughing jaws, glared, blows like beams, rolled on one another, bloody foam whisked through the air; sound images — roared, stifled roar, thunderous smother.)
Seeing the bloody foam fly past, the King remarks to his nobles: "Faith, gentlemen, we're better here than there" — we are lucky to be up here and not down in the pit. It is a humorous, relieved comment; it also shows how dangerous the pit is.
Part 3 (lines 13–18) — The lady's plan
De Lorge's beloved overhears the King's remark. She is a "beauteous lively dame" (a beautiful, high-spirited lady) "with smiling lips and sharp bright eyes, which always seemed the same". Her smile never changes and her eyes are always sharp: the description hints that her smile is fixed and artificial, and her eyes shrewd and calculating. (2027 specimen Q6(v).)
She thinks: the Count, her lover, is as brave as brave can be; surely he would do wonderful things to show his love for her. The King, the ladies, the lovers — everyone is watching; "the occasion is divine" (the perfect opportunity). So she decides: "I'll drop my glove, to prove his love; great glory will be mine."
Her motive is revealed in her own words: not concern for de Lorge, but "great glory" for herself. She wants to test his love and to win attention and admiration before the whole court — vanity. The King's remark ("better here than there") gives her the idea: what could prove love better than going "there"? (2027 specimen Q6(iii).)
Part 4 (lines 19–24) — De Lorge's answer and the King's verdict
She drops her glove into the lions' pit, then looks at him and smiles. De Lorge bows — politely, without a word — and in a moment leaps among the wild lions. His leap is quick, his return is quick, and he is back in his place. Then he throws the glove — "but not with love" — right in the lady's face.
King Francis rises from his seat and exclaims, "rightly done!" He gives his verdict: "No love … but vanity, sets love a task like that." A person who truly loved would never send the beloved into deadly danger merely for show; only vanity sets such a task. (2027 specimen Q6(iv).)
De Lorge's action shows that he has seen through the lady: he proves his courage, but rejects her cruel vanity. By throwing the glove in her face before the whole court, he shames her — publicly, as she had tried to win glory publicly.
Reading between the lines
The ideas behind the images, and why they matter:
- "Valour and love, and a king above, and the royal beasts below." The line is built like a ladder: the King at the top, courage and love in the middle, the lions at the bottom. It shows us at once where everyone sits, and it hints at how far a person could fall from the benches to the pit.
- "Horrid laughing jaws." An open lion's mouth looks like a grin. The word laughing makes the lions seem to enjoy their cruelty, which prepares us for the lady's cruel game.
- "We're better here than there." The King jokes, but he also shows that the pit is truly deadly. This remark gives the lady her idea: it is what she overhears.
- "Smiling lips and sharp bright eyes, which always seemed the same." A real smile changes with feeling. Hers never changes, so it is a mask. Her eyes are sharp because she is calculating, always watching for an advantage.
- "The occasion is divine." Here divine means perfect, as if sent from heaven. She sees the court's attention as a stage for herself.
- "She dropped her glove, to prove his love, then looked at him and smiled." She does not ask him; she drops the glove and smiles. She expects him to obey.
- "He bowed." The bow is polite and silent. It may also be cold, since he has understood her.
- "But not with love." The Count returns the glove to her in the way that tells her what he thinks of her.
- The King's verdict. The King watched the lions for sport and made a joke about them. Yet he condemns the lady. The reason is that the lions are beasts, but de Lorge is a man, and she put his life at risk only for her own glory.
Worked examples
Example 1 (3 marks; ICSE 2025, Q6(iii)). Who was the "beauteous lively dame"? What did she do? What prompted her to do this?
Model answer. She was Count de Lorge's beloved. She dropped her glove into the pit among the fighting lions. She had overheard King Francis say, "Faith, gentlemen, we're better here than there", and saw a chance to test the Count's love and to win glory and admiration for herself before the court.
Why this scores: the identity (1 mark), the action (1 mark) and the prompting, with the King's words or the motive of vanity (1 mark).
Example 2 (3 marks; ICSE 2025, Q6(iv)). Explain in your own words: (a) "smiling lips and sharp bright eyes which always seemed the same" (b) "the occasion is divine" (c) "Faith, gentlemen, we're better here than there".
Model answer. (a) Her smile was fixed and artificial, and her eyes were sharp and calculating; she never showed real feeling. (b) It was the perfect, heaven-sent chance to prove his love and win glory. (c) Truly, gentlemen, we are safer up here in the gallery than down there in the pit with the lions.
Why this scores: one mark for each part, with the idea and not a repeat of the words. The 2025 examiner report says many candidates only rephrased the lines, misunderstood "divine" and failed to say why the King felt safer "here" (in the gallery) than "there" (in the pit among the lions).
In the exam, write: "divine" means perfect or heaven-sent here, not holy.
Example 3 (4 marks; ICSE 2025, Q6(v)). When King Francis exclaims "rightly done!", what action of Count de Lorge does he applaud? Why do you think the Count behaved the way he did?
Model answer. The King applauds the Count's throwing the glove in the lady's face. The Count saw that she had risked his life only to win glory and admiration for herself, so her test was vanity and not love. He was disillusioned and angry, and he wished to shame her in front of the court just as she had tried to win praise before it.
Why this scores: the action is the throwing of the glove, at the lady (2 marks), and the reason shows understanding of her vanity or his anger and wish to humiliate her (2 marks). The report notes that some candidates wrote that the King applauded the leap into the pit. That is wrong.
Example 4 (full extract question, 16 marks). Read the extract and answer.
"By God!" said Francis, "rightly done!" and he rose from where he sat: "No love," quoth he, "but vanity, sets love a task like that."
(i) What did the King do and say after de Lorge threw the glove? [3] (ii) Explain "No love, but vanity, sets love a task like that." [3] (iii) The King had enjoyed the lion fight. Why does he still blame the lady? [3] (iv) What is the tone of the King's verdict? [3] (v) Do you agree with the Count's way of dealing with the lady? Give reasons. [4]
Model answers. (i) He rose from his seat and cried "rightly done!", approving the Count's action of throwing the glove in the lady's face. (ii) The King means that real love would never set its beloved a deadly task just to be admired. Only vanity, the wish for show and glory, would do that. (iii) The lions are beasts fighting in a sport. But the lady put a man's life in danger only so that she could win glory. The King sees the difference between a spectacle and a cruel whim. (iv) The tone is firm and judging; he speaks with calm authority and sums up the matter in one line. (v) I agree. The Count proved that he was brave but did not let himself be used. Throwing the glove back told her, in front of the court, what he thought of her game. Another way might have been to speak to her quietly, but then she might not have learned her lesson.
Why this scores: each answer is short and sticks to its question; (iii) explains the difference between watching a sport and risking a person; (v) gives a clear opinion with reasons and also considers another view.
Example 5 (long answer, 100 to 150 words). Write a character sketch of the lady.
Model answer. The lady is beautiful and lively, but she is vain and cold. The poet describes her "smiling lips and sharp bright eyes, which always seemed the same", which means that her smile is artificial and her eyes are calculating. When she overhears the King's remark, she decides to drop her glove in the pit. Her aim is not to learn about the Count's love but to win "great glory" before the court. She does not think about his danger, and she smiles at him as she drops the glove. She is clever enough to see an opportunity but foolish enough to think that a test of this kind proves love. Her plan ends in public shame.
Why this scores: every trait is supported with a quotation or an action: appearance, vanity, carelessness and result.
Doubts cleared
Q. Why does the King say "we're better here than there"? He is glad to be safe in the gallery and not in the pit. It is a light remark, but the lady uses it as her cue.
Q. Why did de Lorge risk his life if he saw through the lady? The poem does not give his thoughts, but his action tells us. He proves his courage, which shows that he is not afraid, and then he rejects her. That is how he keeps his dignity.
Q. Did the lady love de Lorge? She wished to be admired for having a brave lover, but her act shows that she cared more for glory than for his safety. The King says it is "no love" but vanity.
Q. Who says "No love, but vanity …"? King Francis, in the last line.
Q. What does the word "quoth" mean? It is an old word for "said".
Mistakes to avoid
- Writing that the King applauds the leap into the pit. He applauds the throwing of the glove in the lady's face.
- Copying the line instead of explaining it. For "the occasion is divine" write "the perfect opportunity".
- Calling the lady's smile "sweet" or "kind". The poem says it "always seemed the same", which means it is false.
- Missing the question word. Reading time exists so that you can see whether the question asks about the Count's behaviour or the King's.
Check yourself
- What did the lady do when she heard the King's remark?
- How does the Count respond after bringing back the glove?
- What is the King's verdict on the lady?
Answers: 1. She dropped her glove into the pit to test the Count's love and win glory. 2. He throws the glove in her face. 3. "No love, but vanity, sets love a task like that."